SoccerBars

Turnmill Bar

Home of NYC Evertonians, the official Everton FC supporters club. Owned by Evertonians with authentic memorabilia on the walls. Cozy atmosphere with dark wood and leather booths. Opens at 7:30am for early games. Known for the original "Toffee Brekky" breakfast. Under 21s welcome as they serve food.

New York

About

Sources

4 verified

Researched from 4 independent sources. How we research →

Details

Category: New York
Location: New York , NY
Last Researched: January 26, 2026

More in New York

View all →

Smithfield Hall

The only purpose-built, state-of-the-art soccer bar in NYC. Home to several major supporters clubs including Manchester United (New York Reds), West Ham (NYC Hammers), Barcelona (Penya FC Barcelona NYC), and the American Outlaws Manhattan chapter. Shows every match with full audio. Known for its electric atmosphere on match days.

New York, NY

The Monro Pub

The bar to watch Liverpool in Brooklyn. Cozy British pub owned by husband and wife duo Nicole and Vinny (Liverpool native). Named after Vinny's favorite local in his hometown. Hosts the official Liverpool supporters club of Brooklyn (OLSC Brooklyn). Import beers, craft beers, cocktails, and British snacks.

New York, NY

Black Horse Pub

A strong contender for the best soccer bar in Brooklyn. Popular neighborhood spot with a strong soccer following, particularly for Tottenham Hotspur. Shows EPL, Champions League, World Cup and major matches. Wide selection of craft beers and stellar English pub food. Brooklyn Spurs also gather here.

New York, NY

Olde City

Arsenal NYC's new favorite on Manhattan's West Side starting 2023/24 season. Vintage style with lively matchday crowds and Highbury-inspired charm. Building painted in Arsenal's red and white colors with the crest on the exterior. Arsenal gets top billing with sound priority.

New York, NY